The St. Thomas More Award is given, at the Annual Dinner (in February of the following year), to attorneys exemplifying the intellect, integrity and moral courage of St. Thomas More in service to God, country and profession.
| 2018 | Gerald Dennis Patrick Pratt |
| 2017 | The Honorable Laura Tighe |
| 2016 | Martin Plank |
| 2015 | Brian Bates |
| 2014 | James A. Castle |
| 2013 | R. Livingston Keithley |
| 2012 | L. Michael Brooks, Jr. |
| 2011 | John Eckstein |
| 2010 | Mitchell R. Morrissey |
| 2009 | Suanne M. Dell |
| 2008 | Steve Michalek |
| 2007 | Hon. Jose D.L. Marquez |
| 2006 | Hon. Richard G. McManus, Jr. |
| 2005 | Mark A. Fogg |
| 2004 | Hon. Sheila Rappaport |
| 2003 | Ken Salazar |
| 2002 | Honorable Brian Campbell |
| 2001 | Kevin J. Kuhn |
| 2000 | Bill Ritter, Jr. |
| 1999 | Hon. Mary J. Mullarkey |
| 1998 | James M. Lyons |
| 1997 | Eileen S. Kottenstette |
| 1996 | Harry G. Titcombe, Jr. |
| 1995 | Hon. William Donald Neighbors |
| 1994 | John S. Castellano |
| 1993 | Thomas Quentin Benson |
| 1992 | Hon. John W. Coughlin |
| 1991 | Frances A. Koncilja and Joe Clarence Medina |
| 1990 | Kathleen Mullen |
| 1989 | Hon. Joseph R. Quinn |
| 1988 | Hon. Jim R. Carrigan |
| 1987 | Hon. Leonard P. Plank |
| 1986 | Hon. Karen S. Metzger and Miachel E. Reidy |
| 1985 | Richard D. Casey and Donald A. Klene |
| 1984 | Theodore A. Borillo |
| 1983 | Hon. John L. Kane, Jr. and Donald P. MacDonald |
| 1982 | Hon. James Delaney and Charles J. Onofrio |
| 1981 | T. Raber Taylor |
| 1980 | Hon. Albert Frantz and Anthony F. Zarlengo |
| 1979 | Leonard M. Campbell |
| 1978 | Hon. William Doyle |
| 1977 | Carlos Lucero |